Ensemble Altera: The Four Elements
Pentatone

Christopher Lowrey shows considerable curatorial smarts in his selections for The Four Elements. Its sixteen settings range broadly on both stylistic and temporal grounds, but in assembling them into wind, earth, water, and fire sub-groupings, he and Ensemble Altera achieve a clear sense of unity. While the title's not a misnomer, the seventy-five-minute album in fact presents five categories, its fifth not an element but instead an essence that functions literally and figuratively as a culmination. It's fitting that the final category should contain a single piece, “Salutation,” by one of today's preeminent composers, Eriks Ešenvalds.

He's not the only living composer whose work appears, with settings by Eric Whitacre, Morten Lauridsen, Ivo Antognini, Owain Park, Rebecca Dale, Piers Connor Kennedy, Daniel Gledhill, Michael Garrepy, and Lucy Walker also featured. Those no longer with us but whose work resonates still are William Byrd, Charles Villiers Stanford, and Kenneth Leighton. Testifying to the temporal breadth of the project, The Four Elements extends from a short work by Byrd (1540–1623) to a stirring one by its youngest composer, Walker (b. 1998). Adding to the album's appeal, Garrepy's “Flame of Love” is a world-premiere recording, while Gledhill's “For the beauty of the earth” was the winner of the 2021 Ensemble Altera Composition Competition. It's a release whose wide stylistic swath is such that a piece from the Renaissance sounds as much at home as the African-American Spiritual “Deep river.”

Twenty-four singers compose the full ensemble, with countertenor Lowrey, the group's founder and director, listed as one of its five altos. Their voices illuminate the album concept with vivid performances that lend full weight to meditations that are often celebratory and always affecting. The ensemble delivers the material with reverence and humility, such that appreciation for the life-sustaining support these sacred elements provide is palpably felt. Implicit in the project is the imperative that we must do more to protect those gifts. It's worth noting that the elements are neither static nor unrelated: as Lowrey writes in the release booklet, “Air feeds fire; fire's ash nourishes earth; earth releases minerals into water; water evaporates into air. The wheel turns without ceasing.”

There are moments of time-stopping beauty on the album, and thankfully vocal soloists are identified as they appear. In three cases, instrument sounds accompany the singing, with soprano Rachel Garrepy Beberwyck contributing recorder to the anonymous sixteenth-century song “Westron wynde,” soprano Elijah McCormack and basses Harrison Hintzsche and Simon Whiteley credited with, respectively, finger cymbals, bodhrán, and tambourine on Whitacre's “Leonardo dreams of his flying machine,” and Beberwyck and Hintzsche adding tambourine and bodhrán to Kennedy's “Bailey.” Most pieces are, obviously, arranged for a cappella choir and none the worse for being so.

In the “Wind” grouping, Ensemble Altera's virtuosity is called upon to administer the acrobatics of Park's "The Wings of the Wind," its towering vocal displays crowned by a luminous solo from soprano Sumei Bao-Smith. Tenor Andrew Bearden Brown likewise elevates “Westron wynde” with a lovely turn, the performance otherwise memorable for augmenting harmonies with recorder. Sharing its title with a famous setting by American poet Emily Dickinson, Antognini's soaring “Hope is the thing with feathers” distills the fragility of hope but also its resilience into a stirring statement. Voices flutter like birds' wings through Whitacre's kaleidoscopic “Leonardo dreams of his flying machine,” which, replete with whooshes and percussive flourishes, visualizes in sound the Italian polymath captivated by the notion of flight and the desire to see earth from above.

Speaking of which, the “Earth” section extends from Byrd's polyphonic “Terra tremuit” and Park's majestic “Upheld by Stillness” to the declamatory “Bailey,” written by Kennedy to celebrate the unveiling of the new Castle Bailey Quad at his alma mater, St Peter's College Oxford. It's Gledhill's heartfelt “For the beauty of the earth,” however, that's the most moving setting within the sub-group, not to mention a tremendous vehicle for the ensemble's expressive artistry. We enter “Water” via the haunting folk splendour of “Deep river” (highlighted by baritone Harrison Hintzsche's solo) and one of the recording's most riveting pieces, Stanford's resplendent “The Blue Bird,” Bao-Smith again inducing chills with her voice. “There will come soft rains,” Dale's setting of Sara Teasdale's 1918 poem, perpetuates the hushed beauty of Stanford's. Highlights within “Fire” include Walker's glorious “I saw eternity,” which provides another tremendous outlet for the vocal group's gifts, and Garrepy's transporting “Flame of Love” with its deft fusion of intimacy and ecstasy.

Anyone familiar with Ešenvalds' work won't be surprised by the uplifting beauty of “Salutation,” its words by Bengali poet Rabindranath Tagore set to music of uncommon splendour—“Quintessence” indeed. In text accompanying his “Flame of Love,” Garrepy says of Ensemble Altera that its “singing blends profound intimacy with ecstatic intensity.” Such words clearly could be applied to any number of the magnificent performances on this collection, not just his own.

November 2026